Jan
01
2015

Fake Steve Scalise racism story shopped to blogger by vengeful Scalise opponent.

Not much to add to this story, except for two things:

  1. The Hill should probably start telling its readers soon that Steve Scalise actually talked to a local residents’ association, and not a white supremacists’ group.  Because the Hill’s readers are of the type that will hear about it anyway, and they might start wondering why the Hill hasn’t.
  2. …Rumormonger Gilda Reed lost by fifty points, huh? But didn’t want to use this story because of all the supposed racists in Steve Scalise’s district.  It will shock precisely zero of you that Dr. Gilda Reed is an academic and Democratic agitator of long standing in Louisiana: she was last seen trying to save Mary Landrieu from herself – unsuccessfully.  She’s also demonstrating what I’d call a galloping case of the paranoid jitters if I was any sort of medical health care professional; but I’m not, so I’m just going to note that I’m pretty sure that the Louisiana Republican party probably doesn’t send operatives out to burn down people’s houses*.

Actually… let’s talk a bit more about the second point, for a moment.  Or perhaps a bit ‘around’ the second point.  Might be fruitful.

Come, I will conceal nothing from you: politicians and politicos and political hangers-on leak stuff to bloggers and other New Media types all the time.  They’ll be happy to write the story for you, too – but if you just want to regurgitate the talking points, well, they will just live with that.  Which is a judgmental way of saying that these people are a potential source for us; we just have to know how to use them properly.

Now, the original story as shopped to Cen Lamar (you can find a link to the story via the ‘burn down people’s houses’ link) had a great hook to it: an opposing-side politician with radical ties to a hate group.  And no doubt Mr. Lamar felt gratified at the way that Rep. Scalise, in what is rapidly becoming obvious as an excess of caution, hurriedly apologized for then-state Rep. Scalise speaking with the Jefferson Heights Civic Association (which is the group he actually spoke to**). But what’s happening now is why you have to be careful. Because while I don’t know how well or ill this ends for Steve Scalise – although, judging by the carefully calibrated lack of calls for his head by Democrats, it probably won’t end ill for him at all – I do expect that it won’t end all that well for Mr. Lamar.

And it would have been the easiest thing in the world to get a warning flag on this story.

Source: I got a good one on a Republican Congressman!

Blogger: I’m always up for that.  What do you have?

S: Turns out he was at a white power convention!

B: Ooh.

S: Yeah, I know, right?

B: Tell me you have video.

S: …Umm. No.

B: Dude! You gotta have a camera at these things!  Everybody has them.

S: Well, it was from 2002.

B: OK, fair enough.  What did the transcript of his speech say?

S: …There isn’t a transcript.

B: He gave a speech and there was no transcript? Wait, was he even a Congressman then?

S: State legislator.

B: OK, we can still work with it.  But he was a speaker, right?

S: Yeah!

B: Was he on the program?

S: —

B: There’s going to be a program. :sigh: Is there at least a photo?

S: Well, no.

B: So how do you know that he was at this thing?

S: A guy told us! He said he had a photo. He never gave it to us.

B: Okaaay… How do I get in touch with this guy?

S: You can’t.

That’s when I would have made my excuses and exited, stage right. Because while I don’t mind taking a slap at the opposite side, neither would I want to be in the position of having to explain why I’m effectively the primary source for claiming that a prominent politician is speaking at white power conferences.  Particularly since it’d be my fundament that would get burned in any backblast…

Moe Lane (crosspost)

PS: Guess I had quite a bit to say about it, actually.

*Especially when the person in question is a guy who does political consulting for both Democrats and Republicans.  Geez, Talking Points Memo, you’re the agitprop shop that’s been blessed with a research budget.  Try spending some of it.

**Interesting note here: as Snope dryly points out, that ‘admission’ by Steve Scalise does not actually come out and say Oh, sure, I was there and talked to the white supremacists.  It’s actually better crafted than people are giving Scalise credit for, in fact:

Throughout his career in public service, Mr. Scalise has spoken to hundreds of different groups with a broad range of viewpoints. In every case, he was building support for his policies, not the other way around. In 2002, he made himself available to anyone who wanted to hear his proposal to eliminate slush funds that wasted millions of taxpayer dollars as well as his opposition to a proposed tax increase on middle-class families. He has never been affiliated with the abhorrent group in question. The hate-fueled ignorance and intolerance that group projects is in stark contradiction to what Mr. Scalise believes and practices as a father, a husband, and a devoted Catholic.

10 Comments

  • Aruges says:

    I really wish EE hadn’t jumped on this like he did. I know his hart is in the right place, but he got burned.

  • Antoninus Pius says:

    the facts don’t really matter, do they? the Narrative is that the Republicans are all racist bastards, and that’s all that matters.

    • Luke says:

      This.
      .
      Headlines were made, and the narrative was reinforced.
      Corrections will be buried in fine print on A27, where most people will never see them.
      .
      The damage is done. Republican party leadership has been publicly tarred as racist. That it’s untrue is as irrelevant. The media can be relied upon to continue pushing this narrative.

  • acat says:

    So, now I’m wondering just how many rumors cross Moe’s desk on a weekly basis …
    .
    Mew

  • 1_rick says:

    “That’s when I would have made my excuses and exited, stage right.”

    Yeah, but that’s because you’re smart. I know plenty of liberals who would consider it truthy and put the image you can see on Snopes on their Facebook page and that’s the end of it as far as they’re concerned: more confirmation (as if they needed more) that all Republicans are racist.

    • acat says:

      Preference bias, textbook.
      .
      And all sudes have it … some Conservatives are better than others about fact-checking.
      .
      Mew

RSS feed for comments on this post.



Site by Neil Stevens | Theme by TheBuckmaker.com