It is… worrisome.
The basic problem here that I am having is that it appears that the lead character is reacting to events, not creating them. I don’t recall Kirk, Sisko, or Janeway having this problem (Picard struggled with it a bit, and I didn’t watch enough to see whether Archer did). Put it another way: at one point in that trailer you will see the commander of a Starfleet vessel pause dramatically and say “Run.” As Captain Kathryn Janeway herself might tell you, the proper response in a situation like this would be “Open fire.”
Still, maybe it won’t suck. Or maybe I’m just being cranky. I am, after all, outside of the target demographic these days.